When All The Colors Bleed Into One ([info]solipstone) wrote,
“This is a fucking shame”: an essay

Monday morning, I read on Democracy Now:

“Hurricane Katrina slammed into the Gulf Coast with devastating force Monday morning leaving at least 55 people dead and more than a million people in three states without power. The death toll is expected to rise once rescue units reach the worst hit areas. The number left homeless is unknown. The true extent of the damage may not be known for days. With 145-mile-per hour winds, the storm was ranks as one of the most punishing hurricanes ever to hit the United States. Insurance experts said that damage could range between $9 billion and $16 billion, which would make it one of the costliest storms on record.”

Through the crunch of classes and meetings, I struggled to stay informed as best I could. Trying to read report after report. I don’t have a television, so all I could do was read, trying to take in the numbers, trying to make those numbers into real human beings, who had just lost everything. But then it was time to go to class.

Thursday night, I’m in the library with Kimberly and her friend Nathan. As we walked in, I gave a dollar to the History Club, who was collecting money for the disaster relief. I gave because it was the right thing to do, but the whole thing still wasn’t real to me. Just numbers and numbers and numbers. Not people and families and faces. We find one of the study rooms together, and I trade off between writing a scene from my novel and reading a biography on Che Guevara. At one point, I went downstais to read my e-mail and check out a few websites. I go to OkayPlayer.com, the website owned by The Roots, and discover this link:

http://www.beowt.com/images/looting.gif

I head back upstairs and tell Kim and Nathan about it. Apparently, when starving white people acquire food they desperately need to stay alive, they “find” it. When starving people black people do the same, they are “looters.”

I say: “It’s nice that in times of national crisis, we still find the time to partake in America’s favorite pastime: being racist bastards.”

That night, I sat down for about an hour and watched Democracy Now’s coverage of the catastrophe. I clicked through hundreds of pictures on the internet, sitting on the edge of my chair, tears welling up in my eyes, trying to let those people’s pain come into my heart and become my own pain.

It wasn’t just numbers. It was people.

The destruction. The lost homes. The starvation. The chaos. The crying children. The grieving parents.

The president on vacation.

The next day, President Bush emerges and announces that there will be zero tolerance for “looting,” even for items necessary for survival.

Images of thousands upon thousands stranded outside the Superdome and the Convention Center. No water. No food. Lost children. Lost fathers. Lost mothers. Lost brothers. Lost sisters. Death toll expected to climb towards 10,000.

”No food, no water, no nothing. Whatever we have, we have been taking it. That's the only way we can survive.”

”There is nobody in charge. The national guard, the police, there is nobody. Somebody needs to come take charge and put organization and get these people to safety, to get them clothes, the basics things that they need to live from day-to-day.”

Zero tolerance.

All these people who could not afford to leave. All these people who had nothing in the first place. All these people who were reminded again that America is the land of the free… if you got the cash.

I say out loud in my living room: “Fuck you Bush. If someone is in the middle of a hurricane disaster area and they haven’t eaten for days and they pass by an abandoned grocery store, they have my permission to steal food.”

Zero tolerance.

To quote Damu Smith on Democracy Now:
“I want zero tolerance for that kind of language being used by leaders of our government to discuss poor people, poor black people, who are trying to survive in the -- under the most desperate, insane circumstances. I want zero tolerance for thousands of our troops being sent to Iraq when we need them here. I want zero tolerance for public officials going before the airwaves talking about all of the wonderful things that they're doing when the head of FEMA yesterday said that he didn't even know that there were thousands of black people, thousands of people at the New Orleans convention center between 15,000 and 20,000 people are there with no food and no water and last night, he said he didn't know this. How is that possible? I want zero tolerance for the kind of behavior being exhibited by our national government. Under the leadership of president Bush, which has neglected our people in New Orleans. That's what we need zero tolerance for.”

I wake up this morning and checked the internet news sites. Kanye West, in an act of courage far too rare in today’s artists, went off the script at a television benefit concert and criticized the racist media coverage of Katrina’s poor, black victims.

Here’s the transcript of the segment, featuring Kanye West and Mike Myers:

Myers: The landscape of the city has changed dramatically, tragically and perhaps irreversibly. There is now over 25 feet of water where there was once city streets and thriving neighborhoods.

West: I hate the way they portray us in the media. You see a black family, it says, "They're looting." You see a white family, it says, "They're looking for food." And, you know, it's been five days [waiting for federal help] because most of the people are black. And even for me to complain about it, I would be a hypocrite because I've tried to turn away from the TV because it's too hard to watch. I've even been shopping before even giving a donation, so now I'm calling my business manager right now to see what is the biggest amount I can give, and just to imagine if I was down there, and those are my people down there. So anybody out there that wants to do anything that we can help -- with the way America is set up to help the poor, the black people, the less well-off, as slow as possible. I mean, the Red Cross is doing everything they can. We already realize a lot of people that could help are at war right now, fighting another way -- and they've given them permission to go down and shoot us!

Myers: And subtle, but in many ways even more profoundly devastating, is the lasting damage to the survivors' will to rebuild and remain in the area. The destruction of the spirit of the people of southern Louisiana and Mississippi may end up being the most tragic loss of all.

West: George Bush doesn't care about black people!


Kanye West became my new personal hero.

Then I gave $25.00 dollars to the Red Cross.

Then I prayed for a long time.

Then I wrote this.

-Matthew

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 17 comments

[info]thedivinemsem

September 3 2005, 18:02:51 UTC 6 years ago

My family's from LA. My uncle had to evacuate. He told my grandmother how horrible it is...
And I cannot BELIEVE that article. It made me so angry.
I wish I could just buy a plane ticket into Monroe, grab my PawPaw's car, and make the 1 1/2 hour drive down there to help.

[info]solipstone

September 8 2005, 00:32:26 UTC 6 years ago

Dear Emily,

I sincerely apologize for taking so long to get back to you. The last few days, besides being very stressful academically, have also been filled with finding out that the family of Prof. Francis' husband, who is from New Orleans, was missing for a few days (they are safe and sound now, thank God) and so many other disturbing pieces of news. Keeping up with live journal had suddenly seemed not the most important thing in my life, honestly. But I've had time to clear my head now, and I wanted to thank all of you for responding to my essay and let me know that I was not alone in going almost crazy with anger and grief over the whole situation, and particularly the actions of our government. I too have wanted to jump in a car many times and go help out. Unfortunately, the Red Cross and many other organizations require you to commit yourself for a number of weeks. I can't tell you how many moments of crisis I have had over the past few days where I have just wanted to drop out of school and spent the rest of the semester helping those people rebuild. These are tough times, and I have a bad feeling its only going to get worse. We have to be strong for each other, and that's why I wanted to be sure to write you back and let you know I appreciated you sharing what you were going through. We have to be there for each other. Hopefully I'll be seeing you soon at the radio station. Take care of yourself.

Much love,
Matt

[info]morluna

September 3 2005, 18:53:42 UTC 6 years ago

I feel so disgusted... utterly repulsed... with the way our government is dealing with this crisis. That image... are both of those texts in the same article? My God what is wrong with these people! How can human beings be so lacking in humanity? Like you, I spent a lot of time the last few days trying to put a face with the numbers. I've been looking through pictures of the damage... it's beyond anything I can imagine. The place looks like a warzone. And yeah... Bush is still on vacation. Is that bastard ever NOT on vacation?! I feel sick.

[info]solipstone

September 8 2005, 00:35:21 UTC 6 years ago

Dear Laura,

I basically spilled out all that I wanted to say to you all in response to Emily's post, but just thank you for being there for all of us the past few days. Thank you for being understanding when I looked like I wanted to throw my keyboard out the window during Tech for Teachers. It was wonderful talking to you and Melissa last night. Hopefully we can do that again very, very, soon.

Love,
Matt

[info]divineyaya

September 5 2005, 14:41:28 UTC 6 years ago

One of my friends suggested genocide...

While I'm not sure if I wholeheartedly agree with her there, it is something to think about.
These are her words:
FEMA turned down requests to send busses and other transport to evacuate
those people too old, ill, or poor to drive  cars out of the area, days before the
hurricane, when it was well known that this was a Category 5, and that the
levies could not hold during such high winds. ( I believe the limit for the
levies holding was 115 mph, and the winds were stronger than 150mph). The people
who could not leave  did not have cars to drive, for one thing, or could not
afford the gas. Bush did not care, and is even more of a racist than I thought,
Condalleezza nonwithstanding.

IMHO this is genocide, though not so named.  Almost all of the dead, dying,
and left to die were/are African Americans, and that sure looks like genocide
to me. The government's back was INTENTIONALLY turned on them when there was
still time to get them out. Our government didn't just not think of some public
transportation for them, because it was suggested and refused. (Lots about
this on "Meet the Press" this AM.)

Hopefully Bush and Cheney will be impeached for this one at least.  The death
penalty for all that murder might not be off the wall either.  I've heard
the death toll is now estimated at around ten thousand!  What evil leaders we
have!

An outcry from the world is needed here. 
[the end]

I'm at the MDA telethon right now, so not much time to type.
I feel like I personally failed those people.
More 2later.
Love,
Lyndsey

[info]solipstone

September 8 2005, 00:38:10 UTC 6 years ago

Re: One of my friends suggested genocide...

Dear Lyndsey,

Sorry for taking so long to respond to your post. Your friend definitely made some thought-provoking points. I know I was certainly walking around for a few days greeting friends with "I want Bush impeached so bad right now."

"I feel like I personally failed those people." Unfortunately, I know exactly what you mean.

Hope you're holding up. Take care of yourself.

Love,
Matt

[info]divineyaya

September 10 2005, 03:54:17 UTC 6 years ago

Re: One of my friends suggested genocide...

WE NEVER GOT TOGETHER!
random thought of the day.

But I'll be in Chucktown the weekend after next. Haha, a remedy.....

I shall be calling.

♥,
Lyndsey

[info]solipstone

September 11 2005, 20:01:56 UTC 6 years ago

Re: One of my friends suggested genocide...

Yeah, feel free to give me a call whenever you come into town. I would definitely love to see you. My cell phone is the same (803)361-3842. Until then, take care of your self. Peace, Matt.

Anonymous

September 6 2005, 18:12:26 UTC 6 years ago

Bush is an idiot. FEMA fucked up. And I think very few people (including those involved) understand the reality of the situation. But I do want to talk about the racial aspect of this for a moment.

I find the mere fact this is a racial issue insulting. Black, white, brown, or blue for all I care... they're American, and that they have had to put up with this utter incompetence is a national disgrace. But I'm equally disturbed by people's immediate reaction to dichotomize the issue along political and racial lines. The refugees got piss poor aid because they were and are poor. Their race is an exacerbating factor but not the cause of the problem. The conflict is a racial one in the same sense the Palestinian-Israeli conflict is a religious one. The Palestinians are pissed because someone is occupying their land. The fact they're Muslims and the Israelis are Jewish certainly contributes to the problem, but the fundamental conflict is territorial not religious. The problem here is economic not racial. FEMA left no provisions and took no account of the people simply incapable of evacuating. This is not to say there are not significant cases of discrimination both in the media coverage and the distribution of aid; however, I fear any furtherment of the 'us vs them' mentality which is so prevalant in our society. The racial problems cannot be solved through conflict between black and white people. And claims like 'Aids was created to kill black people' or the actions in New Orleans is some sort of deliberate genocide only serve to further racial divides which we can ill afford when seeking an end to discrimination. Be righteous in your anger but there is no justice in the man consumed by hate whatever his skin.

Strength and Honor,
DJW

[info]solipstone

September 8 2005, 00:11:31 UTC 6 years ago

Dear David,

As always, I am very appreciative of the intelligence and independence of analysis you bring to political issues, but I have to say that I am simply in complete disagreement with you on this issue. I firmly believe that the Katrina disaster and its ensuing aftermath is one of the clearest examples of this government’s classist and racist practices, but let me be very specific about what I mean when I say that. Is it likely that Bush gathered together the head of Homeland Security, the head of FEMA, and all the other members of his cabinet and said “You know what, I really hate all those poor black people in New Orleans. When that hurricane passes through, let’s just sit back and let them die”? No, that’s probably not what happened. But racism is usually much more subtle (and ultimately much more devastating) than burning crosses, the N-word, and outright bigotry.

The white supremacist nature of the American elite had everything to do with the poor and black of New Orleans being left behind. I’m not even talking about the racist disparities between descriptions of white people “finding” food and black people “looting” food. It’s bigger than that. The ultimate truth of the situation is that the poor and black of this country have been left behind for the past four centuries. Was the poverty of Katrina’s victims a major factor in their betrayal? Of course. But we must ask ourselves the real question: why are the vast majority of those neglected poor people also African Americans? Is it just a big coincidence? Or are they just the unlucky masses not able to keep up in Ayn Rand’s vision of meritocracy? No, that is the lie America has been telling itself for generations to ease our conscience over the fact Southern streets were paved with cotton money and our great American wealth was built on black families ripped apart on the auction block, black bodies swinging from trees, and black church burning down to the ground. The apathy that New Orleans’ African American poor experienced this past week after Katrina hit was the same crime they experienced the week before Katrina hit and the crime they’ve experienced their entire lives. That is racism, that is white supremacy, and the Katrina situation has only been the most terrible of reminders that our nation is infected with these diseases still.

Also, I wholeheartedly disagree with your notion that calling out the racist nature of our government’s actions will only create unconstructive tension and facilitate greater feelings of “us vs. them” among African Americans and European Americans. In his “Letter from a Birmingham Jail,” Martin Luther King responded to a similar charge from moderate, white, Southern clergymen that the use of direction action (marches, demonstrations, sit-ins, etc.) would only produce more tension within the community and make Southern whites more resistant to creating an equal society for all Americans. King responded by writing:

“You deplore the demonstrations that are presently taking place in Birmingham. But I am sorry that your statement did not express a similar concern for the conditions that brought the demonstrations into being. I am sure that each of you would want to go beyond the superficial social analyst who looks merely at effects, and does not grapple with underlying causes. I would not hesitate to say that it is unfortunate that so called demonstrations are taking place in Birmingham at this time, but I would say in more emphatic terms that it is even more unfortunate that the white power structure of this city left the Negro community with no other alternative.”

[info]solipstone

September 8 2005, 00:11:49 UTC 6 years ago

King’s statement really goes to the very heart of the matter here. The reaction to the racist practices of our government in response to Katrina does not cause tension, just as the Civil Rights movement did not cause the tension that existed in the segregated South. Protest never creates tension. Injustice creates tension. Oppression creates tension. Inequality creates tension. This goes for New Orleans, Birmingham, Montgomery, Harlem, and any other site of racial injustice. It is the deep-seated causes of this sort of national outrage (poverty, hunger, dehumanization, apathy on the part of government leaders, etc.) that should provoke our anger and despair, not the effects that happen as a result of those underlying causes.

But even when this tension occurs, I also vehemently disagree with your charge that an unconstructive “us vs. them” mentality emerges that creates division between white and black people, at least in the terms by which you define “us” and “them.” The only “us vs. them” mentality that has ever existed in this country in regards to “race” are those who are loyal to the system of white supremacy and those who rebel against it. One’s loyalty to the system of white supremacy is, indeed, not determined by the level of pigmentation in one’s skin. It is determined by whether one believes that the distribution of power and wealth as a result of 400 years of American white supremacy is just or unjust. I, even as a “white” man born and raised in the South, am a proud rebel against the system of white supremacy. Just as I have broken ranks from my supposed “racial” group, there are many African Americans who are loyal to the doctrines of white supremacy and see no injustice in the current political/economic/social reality of American today. It truly has nothing to do with the color of one’s skin, but the determination of one’s conscience. I feel that it should be clearly obvious that when I, a light-skinned person in America, denounces practices that I feel are racist, I am in no way indicting all white people as being guilty of white supremacy. It would be physically impossible for me to hate white people as being incurably racist, when I know first hand that light-skinned people in America have every capacity to become full-fledged freedom fighters against racism and white supremacy.

My anger is solely directed towards those people (of any color) who support (consciously or unconsciously) the system of white supremacy that pushes dark-skinned people down to the bottom of the political/economic/social ladder of this country and pushes light-skinned people to the top. The only people who should in any way feel threatened or under attack by the charges of racism at play in the Katrina catastrophe are those who support white supremacy. And since I know that you hold no prejudice in your heart and disagree profoundly with the philosophy of white supremacy, I do not understand in the least why you would suddenly become defensive when people claim that racism was involved in the slow response by our government to the predominately African American victims on Katrina.

Tension will only cease when there is justice. Harmony between the different colors of humanity will only exist when it is visible in every level of our society – in our government, in our economy, in our culture, and in the way we help those who are struggling. Kanye West remaining silent will never help the situation – in fact, it only makes it worse.

I hope you will consider these words and give them some thought. Though I’m sure you will disagree on many points, just know that I fully believe that your heart is in the right place and that our disagreements are in the tactics, not the goal, of making a better world.

Much love,
Matthew

[info]xerxes480bce

September 8 2005, 02:48:05 UTC 6 years ago

You know I love to be contrarian, Matt :P But I do rather enjoy our discussions as we force each other to think critically about our own positions. I mean I have no idea what would happen if someone in power was only surrounded by people who agreed with them... *coughbushcough* no idea at all. Onto the argument at hand...

I agree with the majority of your arguments. But I do not believe the poor white man suffered less than the poor black man when it came to the Hurricane or the subsequent clusterfuck of a disaster recovery operation. The determining factor in whether the government screwed you over or not was economic class not race. Now, that being said... the Black People suffered more from Katrina because they constituted the majority of poor in New Orleans and That is where the racism lies. As you put it quite correctly, "The apathy that New Orleans’ African American poor experienced this past week after Katrina hit was the same crime they experienced the week before Katrina hit and the crime they’ve experienced their entire lives. That is racism"

As you know I'm a firm believer in attacking problems at their root causes. And I believe in this case the questions asked should be: Why was this allowed to happen to Americans? Then, why were the majority of those Americans affected black?

I hope you understand I am in no why attempting to diminish the suffering of the people affected by Katrina. I simply believe railing against the racist nature of the recovery distracts from the fundamental issues involved and will not ultimately lead to any positive progress.

MfG,
DJW

[info]xerxes480bce

September 6 2005, 18:13:40 UTC 6 years ago

The above post is mine; I just forgot to login.

[info]stretchlikeacat

September 7 2005, 03:56:51 UTC 6 years ago

I keep rereading this entry, Matthew -- I love it. I don't know what else to say -- you've already heard me talk about how I feel about this catastrophe.

[info]solipstone

September 8 2005, 00:21:06 UTC 6 years ago

Dear Melissa,

Thank you very much. I just tried my best to sum up what so many people were feeling, which has been such an outpouring of compassion for the people affected and anger for our government's absolutely criminal activity. Like I said earlier, I have never more felt more love for my countryman and more disgust for the leaders of my country. I hope maybe you'll also read the response I wrote to my friend David on the issue of racism in the Katrina situation. Feel free to respond if you'd like. See you tomorrow morning in class.

Love,
Matthew

[info]jehovahsfitness

September 10 2005, 14:43:46 UTC 6 years ago

Are you going to see Paul Rusesabagina? If so could you give me a ride?

[info]solipstone

September 11 2005, 20:09:22 UTC 6 years ago

Yeah, Melissa and I are definitely going to try to make it. We actually have a class from 4 to 6:45, but we're going to skip out a little early and try to make it down there by at least 6:30. If you'd like to hook up with us, I'm sure we could give you a ride. I don't really know what our definitely plans are at the moment, honestly, but as soon as we work out what we're doing, I'll be sure to let you know. Just give me a call (803-361-3842) sometime tomorrow evening because I have class with Melissa tomorrow afternoon and we'll definitely work something out then. Take care.

Peace,
Matt
Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Facebook Twitter More login options
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…